Board evaluation · Japan edition
Framework and methodology for Japanese listed companies
Aligned with Japan’s Corporate Governance Code.
Our approach
There is no single right way to run a board. There is only the right way for this company, its shareholders and its strategy, and most boards have never consciously chosen it.
For companies listed on the Tokyo Stock Exchange, the review maps to the Code and adds three Japan-specific dials. The output includes the disclosure the Code expects in the Corporate Governance Report.
Additional dials for Japanese companies
| Dial | Turn left | Turn right |
|---|---|---|
| Business relationships ↔ Capital efficiency (cross-shareholdings) | Stable business ties, but capital is locked up and shareholder discipline weakens | Capital efficiency and investor confidence, but strain on long-standing business partners |
| Parent and group alignment ↔ Minority protection (controlling shareholders, listed subsidiaries) | Group coherence and speed, but minority shareholders are sidelined and related-party risk rises | Market confidence, but friction with the parent |
| Management board ↔ Monitoring board | Deep operating knowledge and fast execution, but executives end up supervising themselves | Independent oversight and clear accountability, but less insider knowledge in the room |
Alignment with the Corporate Governance Code
| Code expectation | How the review responds |
|---|---|
| Board effectiveness evaluation and disclosure of a summary of results (Supplementary Principle 4-11-3) | A bilingual (Japanese and English) disclosure summary that sets out specific issues and actions, rather than stopping at “effectiveness has been confirmed” |
| Disclosure of cross-shareholding policy and review of whether each holding is justified (Principle 1-4) | Cross-shareholding dial; review of the board papers and minutes on that review |
| Proportion of independent outside directors at listed subsidiaries, or a special committee (Supplementary Principle 4-8-3) | Controlling-shareholder dial; review of the special committee and related-party transaction procedures |
| Appointment of independent outside directors (one-third or more on the Prime Market, Principle 4-8) | Floor check |
| Skills matrix disclosure (Supplementary Principle 4-11-1) | Tests whether the matrix matches what each director actually contributes |
| TSE request (2023) to manage with awareness of cost of capital and share price | Review of board discussion of capital allocation |
How the review runs
About 6–10 weeks.
-
Week 1
Scope with the chair
Agree objectives, interviewees, documents and the dials that matter most.
-
Weeks 1–3
Desktop review
Articles and board regulations, minutes, board papers, approval-authority rules, disclosures, past effectiveness evaluations.
-
Weeks 2–3
Dial questionnaire
Each director places the board on each dial: where it is now, and where it should be.
-
Weeks 3–6
Interviews and observation
Individual interviews with every director, the kansayaku (or audit and supervisory committee or audit committee members) and key executives, in Japanese or English, with an interpreter where needed; observation of one board meeting.
-
Weeks 6–8
Analysis and dial profile
Stated, observed and needed positions on every dial; floor check; findings by category.
-
Weeks 8–10
Report and board lab
Chair preview, written report, and a half-day session to decide which dials to turn.
-
6–12 months
Follow-up
Check progress on agreed changes and refresh the dial profile.
Read in context
Consensus-building (nemawashi) is a strength when it surfaces disagreement before the meeting, and a weakness when it buries it. The review judges this in the Japanese context rather than imposing a Western benchmark. It also considers the choice of board structure: a company with a kansayaku board, a company with an audit and supervisory committee, or a company with three committees.
Deliverables
-
01
A one-page dial profile
The eight headline dials, showing the stated, observed and needed positions on each.
-
02
Findings by category
And what they mean.
-
03
Results of the floor check
-
04
Recommendations in three tiers
Quick improvements, structural changes, and deliberate “dial adjustments”.
-
05
Feedback to the chair
And to individual directors if wished.
-
06
A bilingual disclosure summary
For the Corporate Governance Report.
Downloads
- Japan edition (English)