Board evaluation
Framework and methodology
How Konigsburg & Co. evaluates boards.
The proposition
There is no single right way to run a board. There is only the right way for this company, its owners and its strategy, and most boards have never stopped to choose it deliberately.
Most board evaluations are checklists. They ask whether the board has the right committees, the right number of independent directors and a skills matrix, and then they score compliance. A board can pass every test and still make poor decisions. A Konigsburg & Co. evaluation works differently.
How it works differently
-
Principles set the floor
Integrity, independence where it matters, fair treatment of shareholders and honest reporting are not negotiable. We check them, briefly.
-
Values set the dial
Above that floor, every governance choice is a trade-off. More central control strengthens oversight but can stifle local initiative. Consensus builds commitment but slows decisions. Long-serving directors bring continuity but can blunt challenge. Each is a dial a board can turn left or right.
-
Three positions on every dial
We show where your board actually sits on each dial, where it believes it sits, and where its strategy and ownership need it to be. The gaps between those three points are where the real findings lie.
The question is not are we compliant? but are we governing the way we mean to, and the way this company needs?
Four foundations
Three are international standards Dan helped shape from the inside; the fourth is two decades of practice advising boards.
| Foundation | Dan’s role | What it brings |
|---|---|---|
| G20/OECD Principles of Corporate Governance | Chair, BIAC Corporate Governance Committee at the OECD, ten years (2016–2025) | The global baseline endorsed by G20 governments: board responsibilities, equitable treatment of shareholders, disclosure, and (since 2023) sustainability and resilience. Sets the floor. |
| ICGN Global Governance Principles | ICGN Board of Governors, six years (2019–2025) | The investor’s view of a good board: leadership, composition, culture, risk oversight, remuneration, accountability. The review sees the board as its owners do. |
| ACGA’s work on governance in Asia | Member, ACGA membership committee (current) | Market-by-market insight into controlling shareholders, family and state ownership, and minority protection, where Western models don’t travel unchanged. |
| Practitioner experience | 15 years leading Deloitte’s Global Center for Corporate Governance; Global Head of Public Affairs, KPMG | The value-driver method itself, tested at previous employers including two of the Big Four, in governance reviews across more than a dozen countries. |
How the standards are used. The principles are not a checklist we score you against. They define the floor and frame the questions we ask on each dial. Where your practice departs from them, we say whether the departure is a deliberate choice that fits your values, or a gap.
Three markers on every dial
Illustrative dial from category 2, Oversight and control, on a scale of 1 to 10. The gap is the finding.
Centralised control
Gain: consistency, control. Risk: slower innovation, local resentment.
Decentralised autonomy
Gain: agility, local initiative. Risk: surprises, uneven standards.
Reading the markers
-
Stated
Where directors and management say the board sits, from the questionnaire, interviews, the charter and the board’s own description of itself.
-
Observed
Where the evidence puts it: minutes, agendas, board papers, delegations, decisions actually taken, and real episodes.
-
Needed
Where the company’s strategy, ownership and market call for it to be. A founder-led growth company and a regulated utility should sit in very different places.
Reading the gaps. If what the board says differs from what it does, the board doesn’t know itself: some think they are Apple, but the company they really have is Berkshire Hathaway. If what it does differs from what the strategy needs, the board knows itself but is misaligned. When all three agree, the dial is well set, even at an extreme. Positions are reported as ranges, never false precision, and every placement rests on evidence the board can test.
Eight headline dials
Each a spectrum between two legitimate values. Neither end is “right”. The chair can swap a headline dial for another in the same category at scoping.
- Purpose and strategy Board-shaped strategy to Management-led strategy
- Oversight and control Centralised control to Decentralised autonomy
- Decision-making and culture Consensus to Delegated authority
- Leadership: chair and CEO Strong CEO to Strong chair and board
- Composition and renewal Insider knowledge to Independent perspective
- Owners and accountability Minimal disclosure to Expansive transparency
- Rewards and incentives Short-term performance to Long-term ownership
- Board process and development Lean to Comprehensive
All the dials
The full report covers every dial.
| Dial | Turn left: gain; risk | Turn right: gain; risk | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 · Purpose and strategy | |||
| Board-shaped strategy ↔ Management-led strategy | Ownership and challenge; blurred accountability, slower decisions | Speed and clear CEO ownership; a board that rubber-stamps | Strategy-day papers, minutes, how often strategy is on the agenda |
| Cash flow and returns ↔ Growth and investment | Discipline and resilience; under-investment | Long-term value; capital that strays from discipline | Capital allocation decisions, dividend and buyback policy |
| Shareholder focus ↔ Stakeholder breadth | Clarity of objective; reputational and social-licence risk | Resilience and trust; diluted accountability | Purpose statement, sustainability oversight, stakeholder engagement |
| 2 · Oversight and control | |||
| Strategic oversight ↔ Operational involvement | Management freedom; issues surfacing late | Early warning; a management board in disguise (“noses in, fingers out”) | Meeting frequency, agenda length, operating detail in papers |
| Centralised control ↔ Decentralised autonomy | Consistency and control; slower innovation, local resentment | Agility and local initiative; surprises, uneven standards | Delegation of authority, subsidiary boards, group policies |
| Risk-averse ↔ Risk-seeking | Protection of the franchise; missed opportunities | Bold bets; exposure beyond what owners signed up for | Risk appetite statement, risk committee papers, major decisions |
| 3 · Decision-making and culture | |||
| Consensus ↔ Delegated authority | Buy-in and cohesion; slow decisions, problems deferred | Speed and accountability; disengaged directors | How decisions are recorded, voting vs consensus, role of committees |
| Harmony ↔ Challenge | Trust and collegiality; problems “papered over” | Candour and rigour; friction, factions | Interviews; minutes that record debate (or don’t) |
| Inside the room ↔ Outside the room | Transparent debate; formality | Speed through informal channels; decisions made before the meeting | Pre-meetings, who talks to whom, surprises at meetings |
| 4 · Leadership: chair and CEO | |||
| Strong CEO ↔ Strong chair and board | Decisive leadership; key-person dependence, weak challenge | Robust counterweight; paralysis, second-guessing | Chair/CEO relationship, CEO goals and evaluation, agenda-setting |
| Chair as convenor ↔ Chair as leader | Neutral process; leadership vacuum in a crisis | Direction and pace; a chair who crowds out the board | Chair role profile, interviews, behaviour in meetings |
| 5 · Composition and renewal | |||
| Insider knowledge ↔ Independent perspective | Deep understanding of the business; groupthink | Fresh challenge; outsiders who don’t grasp the business | Board bios, independence analysis, tenure profile |
| Specialists ↔ Generalists | Expertise on specific risks (AI, cyber, climate); deference to the expert | Broad judgment; technical blind spots | Skills matrix vs how directors actually contribute |
| Continuity (tenure) ↔ Renewal (merit) | Institutional memory; complacency | New thinking; loss of memory, churn | Tenure, succession pipeline, nomination process |
| 6 · Owners and accountability | |||
| Controlling-owner alignment ↔ Minority protection | Long-term stewardship, speed; minorities feel second-class | Market confidence; friction with the controller | Shareholder agreements, related-party transactions, nominee directors |
| Minimal disclosure ↔ Expansive transparency | Confidentiality and focus; investor suspicion | Trust, lower cost of capital; disclosure burden | Annual report, voting results, engagement record |
| Management-led engagement ↔ Director-led engagement | One clear voice; directors insulated from owners | Direct accountability to owners; mixed messages | Investor meetings with the chair, responses to dissent |
| 7 · Rewards and incentives | |||
| Winner-takes-all ↔ Egalitarian | Sharp incentives for stars; resentment, short-termism | Cohesion and fairness; weak differentiation | Pay ratios, CEO pay structure, internal pay dispersion |
| Short-term performance ↔ Long-term ownership | Focus on delivery; gaming targets | Alignment with owners; pay disconnected from performance | Incentive design, holding periods, say-on-pay results |
| 8 · Board process and development | |||
| Lean ↔ Comprehensive | Focus and efficiency; thin information | Thoroughness; long agendas, papers no one reads | Number of meetings, agenda length, timeliness of papers |
| Evaluation as compliance ↔ Evaluation as development | A low-effort annual exercise; nothing changes | Real improvement; requires follow-through and candour | Past evaluations, whether recommendations were implemented |
The floor
Checked, not dialled. Independence where required, conflict-of-interest handling, integrity of financial reporting and audit, equitable treatment of shareholders, and basic board hygiene (charters, minutes, onboarding). If any fall short, they become the first recommendations, whatever the dials show.
How the review runs
Six to ten weeks, one picture.
-
Week 1
Scope with the chair
Agree objectives, interviewees and documents; pick the dials that matter most.
-
Weeks 1–3
Desktop review
Charters, minutes, board papers, delegations, disclosures, past evaluations.
-
Weeks 2–3
Dial questionnaire
Each director places the board on each dial: where it is, and where it should be.
-
Weeks 3–6
Interviews and observation
An hour with every director and key executives; observe one board meeting.
-
Weeks 6–8
Analysis and dial profile
Stated, observed and needed on every dial; floor check; findings by category.
-
Weeks 8–10
Report and board lab
Chair preview, written report, and a half-day session to choose which dials to turn.
-
6–12 months
Follow-up
Check progress on agreed changes and refresh the dial profile.
The questionnaire asks directors to place the board on the dials, not to tick “agree” or “disagree”. Interviews then test those placements against real episodes: a hard decision, a crisis, a disagreement with the CEO. The shorter diagnostic runs steps 1, 2, 4 (chair, CEO and committee chairs only) and 5, in two to four weeks.
What the board receives
A picture of itself, and a plan it owns.
-
01
The dial profile
One page showing the eight headline dials, each with its stated, observed and needed markers.
-
02
Findings by category
What we observed, what it means, and whether each gap is a deliberate trade-off or an unintended drift, with short anonymised quotations.
-
03
The floor check
With any shortfall flagged first.
-
04
Recommendations in three tiers
Quick wins the chair can act on within a quarter; structural changes needing board decisions; and deliberate dial turns, values choices the board should make explicitly.
-
05
A board lab
A facilitated half-day where the board debates the profile and agrees which dials to turn.
-
06
Chair feedback
And optional individual director feedback, given privately.
-
07
A disclosure-ready summary
For the annual or governance report, meeting UK, Japanese and other code expectations.
-
08
A follow-up check
At 6–12 months.
What the review is not: a clean bill of health, a single benchmark imposed on every company, or an instant fix. Boards become effective over time; the evaluation shows them where to aim.
Scope, timing and fees
Three levels.
| Level | What’s included | Timing | Fee |
|---|---|---|---|
| Governance diagnostic | Desktop review, dial questionnaire, interviews with the chair, CEO and committee chairs, dial profile and findings memo | 2–4 weeks | Contact us |
| Full board evaluation | Everything above, plus interviews with every director and selected executives, observation of a board meeting, full report, board lab and disclosure summary | 6–10 weeks | Contact us |
| Add-ons | Individual director feedback; investor perspective interviews (optional, only where the board wants them); subsidiary or group governance review; follow-up | As agreed | Contact us |
Travel is billed separately.
Documents we request
Board and committee charters; articles
Delegation of authority
12 months of agendas and papers; two years of minutes
Director biographies and the skills matrix
Previous evaluations and what came of them
Organisation chart and subsidiary structure
Remuneration policy and recent voting results
Shareholder agreements, where relevant
Investor engagement records and shareholder communications
Confidentiality
Interviews are unattributed. Evaluation data is held under the engagement letter, and anonymised benchmarks are used only with the client’s consent.
Why Konigsburg & Co.
An independent reviewer with nothing else to sell.
-
No search business
Our recommendations on composition aren’t a lead for a director search.
-
No audit conflict
We can review any board, including audit clients of the large firms.
-
Inside knowledge of the standards
Ten years chairing BIAC’s corporate governance work at the OECD, six years on the ICGN board, and an active role at ACGA.
-
International by default
Boards across the Americas, Europe and Asia, in their own governance cultures and often in their own languages.
-
A method with a track record
Tested at previous employers including two of the Big Four, across more than a dozen countries.
-
Senior attention throughout
The person who interviews your directors writes your report and leads your board session.
Country editions
Downloads
- Framework and methodology (full)
- Board evaluation at a glance